Recently Viewed Properties

5 Results

Shelter Island, NY Homes & Apartments For Rent

Add/Edit Locations

Add

Oops! We need you to add a location.
more
Selecting these elements will cause content on the page to be updated. Near by
NEARBY
    Selecting these elements will cause content on the page to be updated. History
    HISTORY
      Save this Search
      Filters
      Selection will refresh the page with new results. properties
      —
      You’ll get email updates when new properties matching this criteria go on the market. You can also run these searches quickly under “Properties & Searches” at the top of every page.

      Filters

      Selection will refresh the page with new results.
      Selection will refresh the page with new results. properties
      PRICE
      to
      BEDROOMS
      BATHROOMS
      STATUS (only include)
      FEATURES

      Add

      Max keywords reached
      Save this Search
      Hide Map
      Order By

      Save this Search

      5 Results

      Shelter Island, NY Homes & Apartments For Rent

      Order By
      9 Johnston Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964View this property at 9 Johnston Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
      9 Johnston RdShelter IslandNY11964

      Use previous and next buttons to navigate

      9 Johnston Rd - Photo 1 9 Johnston Rd - Photo 2 9 Johnston Rd - Photo 3 9 Johnston Rd - Photo 4 9 Johnston Rd - Photo 5 9 Johnston Rd - Photo 6 9 Johnston Rd - Photo 7 9 Johnston Rd - Photo 8 9 Johnston Rd - Photo 9

      1/9

      9 Johnston Rd  Shelter Island, NY 11964

      $8,000
      • Single Family
      • Active
      • MLS # 3547133
      • 4
        Beds
      • 2
        Full Baths
      • 1
        Partial Bath
      • 3
        Total Baths
      Listed by Brown Harris Stevens W Hampton
      47L S Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964View this property at 47L S Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
      47L S Ferry RdShelter IslandNY11964

      Use previous and next buttons to navigate

      47L S Ferry Rd - Photo 1 47L S Ferry Rd - Photo 2 47L S Ferry Rd - Photo 3 47L S Ferry Rd - Photo 4 47L S Ferry Rd - Photo 5 47L S Ferry Rd - Photo 6 47L S Ferry Rd - Photo 7 47L S Ferry Rd - Photo 8 47L S Ferry Rd - Photo 9 47L S Ferry Rd - Photo 10 47L S Ferry Rd - Photo 11 47L S Ferry Rd - Photo 12 47L S Ferry Rd - Photo 13 47L S Ferry Rd - Photo 14 47L S Ferry Rd - Photo 15 47L S Ferry Rd - Photo 16 47L S Ferry Rd - Photo 17 47L S Ferry Rd - Photo 18 47L S Ferry Rd - Photo 19 47L S Ferry Rd - Photo 20 47L S Ferry Rd - Photo 21 47L S Ferry Rd - Photo 22 47L S Ferry Rd - Photo 23 47L S Ferry Rd - Photo 24 47L S Ferry Rd - Photo 25 47L S Ferry Rd - Photo 26 47L S Ferry Rd - Photo 27 47L S Ferry Rd - Photo 28 47L S Ferry Rd - Photo 29 47L S Ferry Rd - Photo 30 47L S Ferry Rd - Photo 31 47L S Ferry Rd - Photo 32 47L S Ferry Rd - Photo 33 47L S Ferry Rd - Photo 34 47L S Ferry Rd - Photo 35 47L S Ferry Rd - Photo 36
      Price Reduced

      1/36

      47L S Ferry Rd  Shelter Island, NY 11964

      $75,000
      -$20,000 (-21.05%)
      • Single Family
      • Active
      • MLS # 3536755
      • Updated 4 days ago
      • 4
        Beds
      • 3
        Full Baths
      • 1
        Partial Bath
      • 4
        Total Baths
      • 3,800
        Sq. Ft.
      Listed by Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
      2 Linda Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964View this property at 2 Linda Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
      2 Linda RdShelter IslandNY11964

      Use previous and next buttons to navigate

      2 Linda Rd - Photo 1 2 Linda Rd - Photo 2 2 Linda Rd - Photo 3 2 Linda Rd - Photo 4 2 Linda Rd - Photo 5 2 Linda Rd - Photo 6 2 Linda Rd - Photo 7 2 Linda Rd - Photo 8 2 Linda Rd - Photo 9 2 Linda Rd - Photo 10 2 Linda Rd - Photo 11 2 Linda Rd - Photo 12 2 Linda Rd - Photo 13 2 Linda Rd - Photo 14 2 Linda Rd - Photo 15 2 Linda Rd - Photo 16 2 Linda Rd - Photo 17 2 Linda Rd - Photo 18 2 Linda Rd - Photo 19

      1/19

      2 Linda Rd  Shelter Island, NY 11964

      $45,000
      • Single Family
      • Active
      • MLS # 3530361
      • 5
        Beds
      • 2
        Full Baths
      • 2
        Total Baths
      • 2,200
        Sq. Ft.
      Listed by Brown Harris Stevens Hamptons
      13 Primrose Pl, Shelter Island, NY 11964View this property at 13 Primrose Pl, Shelter Island, NY 11964
      13 Primrose PlShelter IslandNY11964

      Use previous and next buttons to navigate

      13 Primrose Pl - Photo 1 13 Primrose Pl - Photo 2 13 Primrose Pl - Photo 3 13 Primrose Pl - Photo 4 13 Primrose Pl - Photo 5 13 Primrose Pl - Photo 6 13 Primrose Pl - Photo 7 13 Primrose Pl - Photo 8 13 Primrose Pl - Photo 9 13 Primrose Pl - Photo 10 13 Primrose Pl - Photo 11 13 Primrose Pl - Photo 12 13 Primrose Pl - Photo 13 13 Primrose Pl - Photo 14 13 Primrose Pl - Photo 15 13 Primrose Pl - Photo 16 13 Primrose Pl - Photo 17 13 Primrose Pl - Photo 18 13 Primrose Pl - Photo 19 13 Primrose Pl - Photo 20 13 Primrose Pl - Photo 21 13 Primrose Pl - Photo 22 13 Primrose Pl - Photo 23 13 Primrose Pl - Photo 24 13 Primrose Pl - Photo 25 13 Primrose Pl - Photo 26 13 Primrose Pl - Photo 27 13 Primrose Pl - Photo 28

      1/28

      13 Primrose Pl  Shelter Island, NY 11964

      $25,000
      • Single Family
      • Active
      • MLS # 3527102
      • 4
        Beds
      • 3
        Full Baths
      • 3
        Total Baths
      Listed by Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
      15 Montclair Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11964View this property at 15 Montclair Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11964
      15 Montclair AveShelter IslandNY11964

      Use previous and next buttons to navigate

      15 Montclair Ave - Photo 1 15 Montclair Ave - Photo 2 15 Montclair Ave - Photo 3 15 Montclair Ave - Photo 4 15 Montclair Ave - Photo 5 15 Montclair Ave - Photo 6 15 Montclair Ave - Photo 7 15 Montclair Ave - Photo 8 15 Montclair Ave - Photo 9 15 Montclair Ave - Photo 10 15 Montclair Ave - Photo 11 15 Montclair Ave - Photo 12 15 Montclair Ave - Photo 13 15 Montclair Ave - Photo 14 15 Montclair Ave - Photo 15 15 Montclair Ave - Photo 16 15 Montclair Ave - Photo 17 15 Montclair Ave - Photo 18 15 Montclair Ave - Photo 19 15 Montclair Ave - Photo 20 15 Montclair Ave - Photo 21 15 Montclair Ave - Photo 22 15 Montclair Ave - Photo 23 15 Montclair Ave - Photo 24 15 Montclair Ave - Photo 25 15 Montclair Ave - Photo 26 15 Montclair Ave - Photo 27 15 Montclair Ave - Photo 28 15 Montclair Ave - Photo 29 15 Montclair Ave - Photo 30 15 Montclair Ave - Photo 31 15 Montclair Ave - Photo 32 15 Montclair Ave - Photo 33 15 Montclair Ave - Photo 34 15 Montclair Ave - Photo 35

      1/35

      15 Montclair Ave  Shelter Island, NY 11964

      $75,000
      • Rental
      • Active
      • MLS # 3414136
      • 6
        Beds
      • 4
        Full Baths
      • 1
        Partial Bath
      • 5
        Total Baths
      • 4,600
        Sq. Ft.
      Listed by Corcoran

      Save this searchYou’ll get email updates when new properties matching this criteria go on the market. You can also run these searches quickly under “Properties & Searches” at the top of every page. and receive alerts when new properties are listed.

      Coldwell Banker Realty can help you find Shelter Island apartments and rentals. Refine your Shelter Island rental search results by price, property type, bedrooms, baths and other features. Need more information? View our Shelter Island real estate offices and let us help you find the perfect rental or apartment.

      Cities Near Shelter Island, NY

      ZIP Codes Near Shelter Island, NY

      OneKey MLS logo

      Boundaries © 2014-2018 Pitney Bowes Inc. All rights reserved. School attendance zone boundaries are subject to change. Check with the applicable school district prior to making a decision based on these results.

      Home Partners of America and A New Path to Homeownership are registered trademarks of Home Partners of America LLC.

      Protect your home and budget with an American Home Shield® home warranty. Learn more!

      Coldwell Banker Realty and Guaranteed Rate Affinity, LLC share common ownership and because of this relationship the brokerage may receive a financial or other benefit. You are not required to use Guaranteed Rate Affinity, LLC as a condition of purchase or sale of any real estate. Operating in the state of New York as GR Affinity, LLC in lieu of the legal name Guaranteed Rate Affinity, LLC.

      Real estate agents affiliated with Coldwell Banker are independent contractor sales associates and are not employees of Coldwell Banker.

      © 2024 Coldwell Banker. All Rights Reserved. Coldwell Banker and the Coldwell Banker logos are trademarks of Coldwell Banker Real Estate LLC. The Coldwell Banker® System is comprised of company owned offices which are owned by a subsidiary of Anywhere Advisors LLC and franchised offices which are independently owned and operated. The Coldwell Banker System fully supports the principles of the Fair Housing Act and the Equal Opportunity Act.

      Search options

      We can’t map any of the properties in your results.