Natalie La Mantia

I’m Natalie La Mantia, a client-focused REALTOR® with Coldwell Banker Realty, proudly serving the Tampa Bay area and surrounding suburbs. Known for my integrity and professionalism, I help individuals and families navigate one of life’s biggest decisions with clarity and confidence, providing strong guidance and representation for buyers, sellers, and relocating clients.

With a master’s-level psychology background and post-graduate training in family systems and communication, I bring a calm, steady approach to every transaction. My background as a therapist strengthens my ability to navigate complex conversations, manage stress points, and guide people through high-stakes transitions. Those same skills translate naturally to real estate, where timing, emotions, and strong advocacy matter. My passion for homes and design, paired with my own buying and selling experiences, led me to real estate and reinforced how much the right agent can impact the process. I’m detail-oriented, highly organized, and committed to keeping the process moving smoothly from start to finish.

Anchored by Coldwell Banker Realty, the high-performing Tampa Westshore office, and the trusted support of Team Davis, I’m backed by one of the country’s most respected brokerages, known for exceptional client service, collaboration, and market leadership. Coldwell Banker Realty is part of Compass International Holdings, created when Compass and Anywhere Real Estate combined on January 9, 2026, forming the largest U.S. real estate brokerage by sales volume and connecting roughly 340,000 real estate professionals. That scale helps sellers gain broader exposure and helps buyers benefit from strong connections and resources, especially for relocation and referrals. Team Davis is a fifth-generation family rooted on Florida’s Gulf Coast and has been full-time REALTORS® since 2004, offering deep local knowledge, sophisticated negotiation strategy, and a reputation built on results. Their established network and strategic guidance strengthen my ability to leverage pricing precision, local market insight, and tech-driven marketing to deliver elevated representation at every stage of the transaction. That support helps me deliver a smooth, well-organized experience for my clients. I’m calm under pressure, solution-focused, and skilled at turning complex steps into a clear plan.

I’m deeply connected to the Tampa Bay area and its surrounding suburbs, and I view it as an exceptional place to live, work, and build a life. As a local family business owner and proud FishHawk resident raising my children here, I’m truly invested in the community. I’m also involved with the FishHawk Mombies community fundraiser raising awareness for breast cancer, and in my free time I enjoy exploring Tampa’s neighborhoods, restaurants, and waterfront.

From Tampa’s coastal beauty and warm weather to its family-friendly neighborhoods, vibrant dining scene, and growing business landscape, I love helping individuals, families, and newcomers discover what makes this community so special. I value relationships and see every closing as a beginning, not an end, remaining a trusted resource well beyond the sale.

If you’re thinking about buying, selling, or relocating in Tampa Bay, I’d love to help you create a clear plan and move forward with confidence, and to be your trusted advocate for years to come.