Recently Viewed Properties
See This Home
Save This Listing
Close

View All Photos

$1,999,999 Just Listed

  • For Sale
  • Active
  • Single Family
  • 9 Beds
  • 4 Full Baths
  • 1 Partial Bath
  • 3 Car Garage
  • Updated 4 days ago
See This Home
Save This Home
See This Home
Save This Home
Step into timeless elegance with this stately 9 bedroom 4.5 bath Federal Style home encompassing over 5,646 square feet of living space. Built in 1890, this grand home is steeped in rich history- once owned by George Macy, the famed tea importer. This architectural gem showcases classic period details including four fireplaces, intricate woodwork and moldings, high ceilings, and generously proportioned rooms. The gracious formal living and dining room are ideal for inside entertaining, while a specious deck allows for fabulous outdoor entertaining. This home sits on an expansive 1.4 acre lot and includes a 3-car detached garage, mature landscaping, and a commanding presence that reflects its storied past. With nine spacious bedrooms and four and a half baths, this is a rare opportunity to own a piece of history in an area known for it's prestigious homes and legacy properties.

Full Property Details for 35 S Penataquit Ave

General

  • Price: $1,999,999
  • Taxes: $25,395
  • Status: Active
  • Type: Single Family
  • Source: Long_Island
  • MLS ID: 944725
  • Updated: 4/10/2026
  • Added to Site: 4 day(s) ago

Interior

  • Number of Rooms: 18
  • Interior Features: Eat-in Kitchen, Entrance Foyer, Formal Dining, High Ceilings, Primary Bathroom, Storage
  • Fireplace: Yes
  • Number of Fireplaces: 4
  • Appliances: Dishwasher, Disposal, Dryer, Electric Oven, Gas Cooktop, Gas Oven, Gas Range, Refrigerator, Stainless Steel Appliance(s), Trash Compactor, Washer, Gas Water Heater, Wine Refrigerator

Rooms

Bathrooms

  • Total Bathrooms: 5
  • Full Bathrooms: 4
  • Half Bathrooms: 1

Bedrooms

  • Total Bedrooms: 9

Exterior

  • Porch/Patio/Deck: Deck, Porch

Parking

  • Garage: Yes
  • Garage Spaces: 3
  • Parking Features: Garage

Location

  • County: Suffolk County
  • Driving Directions: Montauk Hwy to S.Penataquit to #35. House is on the right

School Information

  • High School District: Bay Shore
  • Elementary School: Brook Avenue Elementary School
  • Middle School: Bay Shore Middle School
  • High School: Bay Shore Senior High School

Heating & Cooling

  • Cooling Type: Ductless, Wall/Window Unit(s)
  • Heating Type: Natural Gas
  • Heating Zones: 5

Utilities

  • Sewer: Public Sewer
  • Water: Public
  • Utility Description: Natural Gas Connected

Structural Information

  • Architectural Style: Other
  • Detached/Attached: Detached
  • Construction: Cedar, Frame
  • Basement: Yes
  • Basement Desc.: Full Basement, Partially Finished
  • Sq. Ft. Source: Public Records
  • Year Built: 1890

Lot Features

  • Lot Size (Acres): 1.4
  • Lot Size (Sq. Ft.): 60,984

Financial Considerations

  • Tax Amount: $25,395.99

Disclosures and Reports

  • Special Conditions: None
  • Exclusions: Kitchen and Dining Room Chandeliers
  • Property ID: 0500-394-00-02-00-027-000
  • Block: 2
  • Lot Number: 27

Listed by Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

Quickly Find Out More

* Indicates a required field

Yes, I would like more information. Please use and/or share my information with a Coldwell Banker ® affiliated agent to contact me about my real estate needs. By clicking Send Message, I request to be contacted by phone or text message and consent to being contacted by automated means. I understand that my consent to receive calls or texts is not a condition of purchasing any property, goods, or services. Alternatively, I understand that I can access real estate services by email or I can contact the agent myself.

If an Coldwell Banker affiliated agent is not available in the area where I need assistance, I agree to be contacted by a real estate agent affiliated with another brand owned or licensed by Anywhere Real Estate (BHGRE®, CENTURY 21®, Corcoran®, ERA®, or Sotheby’s International Realty®). I acknowledge that I have read and agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Notice.

We Value Your Privacy

Listing agent

— 35 S Penataquit Ave —

  • Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

631-647-7013

Get Pre-Approved Today

Be ready to buy your new home!

with our affiliated lender
NMLS#: 1598647

Get Pre-Approved

Be ready to buy your new home!

with our affiliated lender
NMLS#: 1598647

Get Pre-Approved

Schools serving 35 S Penataquit Ave

School District:Bay Shore Union Free School District
NameGradesDistance
Brook Avenue Elementary School
45 Brook Avenue, Bay Shore, NY 11706
K-20.9 mi
South Country School
885 Hampshire Road, Bay Shore, NY 11706
3-52.2 mi
Disclaimer: School attendance boundaries provided by ATTOM Data Solutions and are for reference only. Contact the school directly to verify enrollment eligibility.

Price & Sales History for 35 S Penataquit Ave Get Price Alerts and Save Property

Date
Details
Price
Change
Source
4/10/2026
Listed
$1,999,999
73.91%
MLS
5/31/2013
Sold
$1,150,000
—
Public Record
Get Price Alerts and Save Property
Disclaimer: Historical sales information is derived from public records provided by the county offices. Information is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.

Tax History for 35 S Penataquit Ave

Year
Property Taxes
Change
Tax Assessment
Change
2020
100%
$77,900
—
2022
-100%
$77,900
—
2016
$21,068
4%
$77,900
—
2017
$20,279
—
$77,900
—
2016
$20,275
-1%
$77,900
—
2015
$20,385
—
$77,900
—
2015
$20,434
1%
$77,900
—
2014
$20,144
5%
$77,900
—
2013
$19,158
—
$77,900
—
Disclaimer: Historical tax information is derived from public records provided by the county offices. Information is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.

Estimate the Cost for 35 S Penataquit Ave

$
Down Payment
%
$
%

$
$

*These costs are estimates, and the interest rates assume exceptional credit standing.

Listed by Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

35 S Penataquit Avenue, Bay Shore, NY 11706 (MLS# 944725) is a Single Family property with 9 bedrooms, 4 full bathrooms and 1 partial bathroom. 35 S Penataquit Avenue is currently listed for $1,999,999 and was received on April 10, 2026. Want to learn more about 35 S Penataquit Avenue? Do you have questions about finding other Single Family real estate for sale in Bay Shore? You can browse all Bay Shore real estate or contact a Coldwell Banker agent to request more information.

Tour this property