131 E Chestnut Street, Lancaster, OH 43130 - Photo 1

1/1

$387,900

Sold
Closed
Single Family
4 Beds
2 Full Baths
4,284 Sq. Ft.
0.08 Acres

1/1

Property Description

Find your sanctuary in this one-of-a-kind home! Originally build in 1851 as Emmanuel Lutheran Church, later known as the B'Nai Israel synagogue, and is currently a converted private residence. This versatile open-concept design offers 4 bedrooms, 2 full baths, a large kitchen with a walk-in pantry, a generous recreation room complete with pool table. This historical property blends preserved architectural elements with modern living features including gothic stained-glass windows throughout, arched church doors, soaring vaulted ceilings, original hardwoods, and a bell tower. Perfect for artists, musicians, or continue as Airbnb revenue. Minutes from downtown's vibrant art galleries and museums, coffee shops and restaurants. If you're looking for a property with profound history, architectural beauty, and endless creative potential, make your appointment today!

Full Property Details

Full Property Details for 131 E Chestnut St

General

Sold For: $387,900
Taxes: $2,375 (2024)
Status: Closed
Type: Single Family
Source: Columbus_N_Greater_Ohio
MLS ID: 225026079
Added to Site: 262 day(s) ago

Interior

Flooring: Wood, Carpet

Rooms

Bathrooms

Total Bathrooms: 2
Full Bathrooms: 2
Upper Floor Baths: 1
Main - Full Baths: 1

Bedrooms

Total Bedrooms: 4

Parking

Parking Features: On Street

Location

County: Fairfield
Township: None

School Information

School District: LANCASTER CSD 2305 FAI CO.

Heating & Cooling

Central air: Yes
Air Conditioning: Yes
Cooling Type: Central Air, Window Unit(s)
Heating Type: Forced Air

Utilities

Sewer: Public Sewer
Water: Public

Structural Information

Basement: Yes
Basement Desc.: Crawl Space
Square Feet: 4,284
Sq. Ft. Source: Realist
Living Area: 4,284 Sq. Ft.
Finished Total: 4,284 Sq. Ft.
Year Built: 1900

Lot Features

Lot Size (Acres): 0.08
Lot Size (Sq. Ft.): 3,484.8
Potential Use: Commercial

Financial Considerations

Price Per Sq. Ft.: $93.35
Tax Amount: $2,375
Tax Year: 2024
Terms: Conventional

Disclosures and Reports

Property ID: 05-35049-300

Listed by Howard Hanna Real Estate Servc (740) 689-9090, Jenifer M Campbell (740) 407-4343 and Howard Hanna Real Estate Servc (740) 689-9090, Allan Anderson (740) 503-0452
Sold by Keller Williams Greater Cols (614) 944-5900, Michael Casey Valentine

What's Your Home Worth?

* Indicates a required field

For a complimentary comparative market analysis, please contact us so we can discuss your home's value.

Your Property Information

Address optional

City *State *

Zip Code *

Your Contact Information

First Name *Last Name *

Email Address *

Phone Number *

Comment *

Yes, I would like more information. Please use and/or share my information with a Coldwell Banker ® affiliated agent to contact me about my real estate needs. By clicking Submit, I request to be contacted by phone or text message and consent to being contacted by automated means. I understand that my consent to receive calls or texts is not a condition of purchasing any property, goods, or services. Alternatively, I understand that I can access real estate services by email or I can contact the agent myself.

If an Coldwell Banker affiliated agent is not available in the area where I need assistance, I agree to be contacted by a real estate agent affiliated with another brand owned or licensed by Anywhere Real Estate (BHGRE®, CENTURY 21®, Corcoran®, ERA®, or Sotheby’s International Realty®). I acknowledge that I have read and agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Notice.

Listing agents

— 131 E Chestnut St —

Jenifer M Campbell

Howard Hanna Real Estate Servc

740-689-9090
Allan Anderson

Howard Hanna Real Estate Servc

740-689-9090

Get Pre-Approved Today

Be ready to buy your new home!

with our affiliated lender

NMLS#: 1598647

Get Pre-Approved

Schools

Schools serving 131 E Chestnut St

School District:Lancaster City School District

Name	Grades	Distance
Thomas Ewing Junior High School 2024 Sheridan Drive, Lancaster, OH 43130	6-8	3.1 mi
Lancaster High School 1312 Granville Pike, Lancaster, OH 43130	9-12	1.6 mi

Disclaimer: School attendance boundaries provided by ATTOM Data Solutions and are for reference only. Contact the school directly to verify enrollment eligibility.

Price & Sales History for 131 E Chestnut St

Date

Details

Price

Change

Source

11/12/2025

Sold

$387,900

-3%

MLS

8/28/2025

Price Reduced

$399,900

-5.88%

MLS

8/07/2025

Price Reduced

$424,900

-2.99%

MLS

7/29/2025

Price Reduced

$438,000

-2.67%

MLS

7/15/2025

Listed

$450,000

—

MLS

Disclaimer: Historical sales information is derived from public records provided by the county offices. Information is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.

474 Natchez Ln, Sugar Grove, OH 43155 - Photo 1

Just Listed

$289,900

474 Natchez Ln Sugar Grove, OH 43155

Single Family
Active
Updated 2 days ago

3
Beds
2
Total Baths
1,890
Sq. Ft.

Listed by Sorrell & Company, Inc. (614) 488-0707, Jeff Shaw (614) 648-1920

100 N Elm St, Sugar Grove, OH 43155 - Photo 1

Price Reduced

-$15,000 (-9.38%)

$144,900

100 N Elm St Sugar Grove, OH 43155

Single Family
Active
Updated 2 days ago

4
Beds
2
Total Baths
1,424
Sq. Ft.

Listed by Howard Hanna Real Estate Servc (740) 689-9090, David W Hughes (740) 438-1311

592 Catawba Ct, Sugar Grove, OH 43155 - Photo 1

Just Listed

$339,990

592 Catawba Ct Sugar Grove, OH 43155

Single Family
Active
Updated 4 days ago

3
Beds
2
Total Baths
1,536
Sq. Ft.

Listed by e-Merge Real Estate (614) 678-5505, Guy Reece (614) 516-1901

28430 Hide a Way Hills Rd, Sugar Grove, OH 43155 - Photo 1

Just Listed

$339,900

28430 Hide a Way Hills Rd Sugar Grove, OH 43155

Single Family
Active
Updated 3 days ago

3
Beds
2
Total Baths
1,200
Sq. Ft.

Listed by Bartlett Benner Realty (740) 654-1500, Tony Coakley (740) 215-6487

901 Kato Ct, Sugar Grove, OH 43155 - Photo 1

Price Reduced

-$10,000 (-2%)

$489,900

901 Kato Ct Sugar Grove, OH 43155

Single Family
Active
Updated 22 hours ago

3
Beds
3
Total Baths
2,491
Sq. Ft.

Listed by Key Realty (877) 539-7589, Ronald C Newman (614) 302-0049

Price Reduced

-$15,000 (-9.38%)

$144,900

100 N Elm St Sugar Grove, OH 43155

Single Family
Active
Updated 2 days ago

4
Beds
2
Total Baths
1,424
Sq. Ft.

Listed by Howard Hanna Real Estate Servc (740) 689-9090, David W Hughes (740) 438-1311

5850 Borah Hill Rd, Sugar Grove, OH 43155 - Photo 1

Price Reduced

-$10,000 (-2.78%)

$349,900

5850 Borah Hill Rd Sugar Grove, OH 43155

Single Family
Active
Updated 6 days ago

3
Beds
2
Total Baths
2,069
Sq. Ft.

Listed by Howard HannaRealEstateServices (740) 687-1516, Dean Bradford (740) 777-0328

1640 Cardinal Hill Ln, Sugar Grove, OH 43155 - Photo 1

Price Reduced

-$25,000 (-4.17%)

$574,900

1640 Cardinal Hill Ln Sugar Grove, OH 43155

Single Family
Active
Updated 6 days ago

3
Beds
3
Total Baths
3,180
Sq. Ft.

Listed by Century 21 Darfus Realty (740) 687-1011, Melissa Frank (740) 407-3188

115 E Wheeling St, Lancaster, OH 43130 - Photo 1

Sold

$410,000

115 E Wheeling St Lancaster, OH 43130

Single Family
Closed

4
Beds
4
Total Baths
4,400
Sq. Ft.

Listed by Keller Williams Greater Cols (614) 944-5900, Zachary T DeLeon (740) 503-8912
Sold by Buckeye Roots Realty, LLC (740) 503-0468, Megan Clara Ramsey

405 N Broad St, Lancaster, OH 43130 - Photo 1

Sold

$391,500

405 N Broad St Lancaster, OH 43130

Single Family
Closed

4
Beds
3
Total Baths
3,269
Sq. Ft.

Listed by Keller Williams Greater Cols (614) 944-5900, Roderick A Williams (740) 974-0818
Sold by Keller Williams Greater Cols (614) 944-5900, Michael Casey Valentine

239 King St, Lancaster, OH 43130 - Photo 1

Sold

$372,900

239 King St Lancaster, OH 43130

Single Family
Closed

3
Beds
3
Total Baths
2,140
Sq. Ft.

Listed by Key Realty (877) 539-7589, Kimberly A Cumbo (740) 808-0263
Sold by Non Member Office (740) 808-0263, NON MEMBER

171-173 E 6th Ave, Lancaster, OH 43130 - Photo 1

Sold

$407,500

171-173 E 6th Ave Lancaster, OH 43130

Duplex
Closed

Listed by Red 1 Realty (614) 585-9020, Melissa Adams (614) 989-4812
Sold by Real of Ohio (855) 450-0442, Justin Bruce

131 E Chestnut Street, Lancaster, OH 43130 (MLS# 225026079) is a Single Family property that was sold at $387,900 on November 12, 2025. Want to learn more about 131 E Chestnut Street? Do you have questions about finding other Single Family real estate for sale in Lancaster? You can browse all Lancaster real estate or contact a Coldwell Banker agent to request more information.

131 E Chestnut St Lancaster, OH 43130