Recently Viewed Properties
See This Home
Save This Listing
Close

$2,500,000

  • Sold
  • Closed
  • Single Family
  • 3 Beds
  • 2 Full Baths
See This Home
Save This Home
See This Home
Save This Home
This waterfront home with deep water dock is a boater's dream. A cozy beach home featuring 3 bedrooms, 2 full baths, a 2 car garage, and outdoor shower, all tucked down a quiet dead-end road, in the sought after Silver Beach area. Enjoy breathtaking sunrises from this spacious yard overlooking West Neck Creek, and a nature preserve. This wonderful home is near the most desirable beaches on Shelter Island., Additional information: Interior Features:Lr/Dr

Full Property Details for 5 Bay Shore Dr

General

  • Sold For: $2,500,000
  • Taxes: $14,692
  • Status: Closed
  • Type: Single Family
  • Source: Long_Island
  • MLS ID: L3590276
  • Added to Site: 435 day(s) ago

Interior

  • Number of Rooms: 8
  • Interior Features: Master Downstairs, First Floor Bedroom, Primary Bathroom, Ceiling Fan(s)
  • Fireplace: Yes
  • Number of Fireplaces: 1
  • Fireplace(s): Wood Burning Stove
  • Appliances: Indirect Water Heater, Oil Water Heater, Dishwasher, Dryer, Microwave, Refrigerator, Washer
  • Flooring: Hardwood

Rooms

Bathrooms

  • Total Bathrooms: 2
  • Full Bathrooms: 2

Bedrooms

  • Total Bedrooms: 3

Exterior

  • Exterior Features: Dock
  • Porch/Patio/Deck: Patio

Parking

  • Garage: Yes
  • Parking Features: Private, Attached, Garage Door Opener

Location

  • County: Suffolk County
  • Cross Streets: Petticoat Ln

School Information

  • High School District: Shelter Island
  • Elementary School: Shelter Island School
  • Middle School: Shelter Island School
  • High School: Shelter Island School

Heating & Cooling

  • Central air: Yes
  • Cooling Type: Central Air
  • Heating Type: Oil, Baseboard

Utilities

  • Sewer: Cesspool
  • Water: Private, Well

Structural Information

  • Architectural Style: Ranch
  • Detached/Attached: Detached
  • Construction: Frame, Cedar, Shake Siding
  • Basement: Yes
  • Basement Desc.: Full Basement, Unfinished
  • Windows: Blinds, Screens, Skylight(s)
  • Sq. Ft. Source: Plans
  • Year Built: 1954

Lot Features

  • Property View: Panoramic
  • Lot Size (Sq. Ft.): 23,087
  • Lot Dimensions: .53

Water Features

  • Water Front: Yes
  • Water Front View: Beach Front, Creek, Waterfront, Water Access

Financial Considerations

  • Tax Amount: $14,692.04

Disclosures and Reports

  • Property ID: 0700-022-00-01-00-011-000
  • Block: 1
  • Lot Number: 11

Listed by Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Sold by Saunders & Associates

Listing agent

— 5 Bay Shore Dr —

  • Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

631-749-1155

Get Pre-Approved Today

Be ready to buy your new home!

with our affiliated lender
NMLS#: 1598647

Get Pre-Approved

Be ready to buy your new home!

with our affiliated lender
NMLS#: 1598647

Get Pre-Approved

Schools serving 5 Bay Shore Dr

School District:Shelter Island Union Free School District
NameGradesDistance
Shelter Island School
33 North Ferry Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964
PK-121.4 mi
Disclaimer: School attendance boundaries provided by Pitney Bowes and are for reference only. Contact the school directly to verify enrollment eligibility.

Price & Sales History for 5 Bay Shore Dr

Date
Details
Price
Change
Source
8/14/2025
Sold
$2,500,000
-9.09%
MLS
6/11/2025
Price Reduced
$2,750,000
-8.03%
MLS
1/24/2025
Price Reduced
$2,990,000
-9.39%
MLS
11/09/2024
Listed
$3,300,000
—
MLS
Disclaimer: Historical sales information is derived from public records provided by the county offices. Information is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.

Listed by Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Sold by Saunders & Associates

5 Bay Shore Drive, Shelter Island, NY 11964 (MLS# L3590276) is a Single Family property that was sold at $2,500,000 on August 14, 2025. Want to learn more about 5 Bay Shore Drive? Do you have questions about finding other Single Family real estate for sale in Shelter Island? You can browse all Shelter Island real estate or contact a Coldwell Banker agent to request more information.