1258 Main Street, East Earl, PA 17519 - Photo 1

1/1

$419,000

Sold
Closed
Single Family
5,571 Sq. Ft.
2 Car Garage
Updated 9 days ago

1/1

Property Description

Spacious and full of opportunity, this 3,500+ sq. ft. duplex offers incredible versatility and income potential in a highly desirable location - just minutes from New Holland and right up the road from Shady Maple. Backing directly to Blue Ball Elementary, you'll enjoy views of open sports fields and tennis courts - adding a sense of community, safety, and space that tenants and owners alike will love. Situated on .74 acres of flat land, this property features tall ceilings, generous living spaces, and multiple structures that expand its investment appeal. The detached garage provides additional rental income or storage potential, while the detached summer kitchen offers an ideal space to convert into a short-term rental, studio, or in-law suite. Estimated market rent projections; Unit 1258; $1,500 - $1,600 Unit 1246; $1,400 - $1,500 Two car garage - $75 per bay. Whether you're a young investor looking to house hack or a seasoned investor seeking a value-adding asset, this property delivers. With its prime location, growing market demand, and flexible setup, this is a value-increasing opportunity that's ready to reward the right owner. Don't miss this chance to own a unique, income-producing property with room to grow and plenty of upside in one of Lancaster County's most sought-after areas.

Full Property Details

Full Property Details for 1258 Main St

General

Sold For: $419,000
Taxes: $5,426 (2025)
Status: Closed
Type: Single Family
Source: BrightMLSPhilly
MLS ID: PALA2079120
Added to Site: 149 day(s) ago

Rental Information

Lease Info: Month to Month

Interior

Interior Features: Attic, Floor Plan - Traditional

Parking

Garage: Yes
Garage Spaces: 2
Total Spaces: 6
Parking Type: Detached Garage, Driveway, Off Street
Garage Description: Additional Storage Area, Covered Parking

Location

Area: East Earl Twp (10520)
Municipality: EAST EARL TWP
County: LANCASTER
Subdivision: EAST EARL TWP
Driving Directions: GPS

School Information

School District: Eastern Lancaster County

Heating & Cooling

Cooling Type: None
Heating Type: Radiator, Hot Water
Heating Fuel: Oil
Water Heater: Electric

Utilities

Sewer: Public Sewer
Water: Well

Structural Information

Architectural Style: Traditional
Structure Type: Detached
Construction: Stone
Basement: Yes
Basement Desc.: Unfinished, Sump Pump
Foundation: Stone
Roof: Composite, Shingle
Square Feet: 5,571
Sq. Ft. Source: Estimated
Living Area: 3,714 Sq. Ft.
Finished Above Grnd: 3,714 Sq. Ft.
Year Built: 1890
Year Built Source: Assessor
Property Condition: Good

Unit Information

Other Units: Unit 1, Unit 2

Additional Structures

Other Structures: Spring House

Lot Features

Lot Size (Acres): 0.74
Lot Size (Sq. Ft.): 32,234
Lot Size Source: Assessor
Zoning: RESIDENTIAL

Financial Considerations

Price Per Sq. Ft.: $112.82
Assessment Year: 2025
School Tax: $4,079
City/TownTax: $496
City/TownTax Freq: Annually
County Tax: $850
County Tax Freq: Annually
Tax w/Assessment: $292,000
Tax Amount: $5,426
Tax Year: 2025
Terms: Standard Sale
Owner Pays: Sewer
Tax Total Finished Sq. Ft.: 3714

Disclosures and Reports

Ownership: Fee Simple
Exclusions: Appliances (Tenant Owned)

Listed by Astoria Realty Advisors LLC, Ethan Cole Sensenig and Keller Williams Elite, Benuel Esh
Sold by Kingsway Realty - Ephrata, Wendy L Stauffer

What's Your Home Worth?

* Indicates a required field

For a complimentary comparative market analysis, please contact us so we can discuss your home's value.

Your Property Information

Address optional

City *State *

Zip Code optional

Your Contact Information

First Name *Last Name *

Email Address *

Phone Number *

Comment *

Yes, I would like more information. Please use and/or share my information with a Coldwell Banker ® affiliated agent to contact me about my real estate needs. By clicking Submit, I request to be contacted by phone or text message and consent to being contacted by automated means. I understand that my consent to receive calls or texts is not a condition of purchasing any property, goods, or services. Alternatively, I understand that I can access real estate services by email or I can contact the agent myself.

If an Coldwell Banker affiliated agent is not available in the area where I need assistance, I agree to be contacted by a real estate agent affiliated with another brand owned or licensed by Anywhere Real Estate (BHGRE®, CENTURY 21®, Corcoran®, ERA®, or Sotheby’s International Realty®). I acknowledge that I have read and agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Notice.

Listing agents

— 1258 Main St —

Ethan Cole Sensenig

Astoria Realty Advisors LLC
Benuel Esh

Keller Williams Elite

Listing Office Email: chris@thechrisgoodteam.com

Get Pre-Approved Today

Be ready to buy your new home!

with our affiliated lender

NMLS#: 1598647

Get Pre-Approved

Schools

Schools serving 1258 Main St

School District:Eastern Lancaster County School District

Name	Grades	Distance
Blue Ball El School 126 Ewell Road, East Earl, PA 17519	K-6	0.1 mi
Garden Spot Middle School 669 East Main Street, New Holland, PA 17557	7-8	1.8 mi
Garden Spot Senior High School 669 East Main Street, New Holland, PA 17557	9-12	1.8 mi

Disclaimer: School attendance boundaries provided by ATTOM Data Solutions and are for reference only. Contact the school directly to verify enrollment eligibility.

Price & Sales History for 1258 Main St

Date

Details

Price

Change

Source

3/30/2026

Sold

$419,000

—

MLS

1/23/2026

Price Reduced

$419,000

-2.33%

MLS

1/12/2026

Price Reduced

$429,000

-2.28%

MLS

11/12/2025

Listed

$439,000

—

MLS

Disclaimer: Historical sales information is derived from public records provided by the county offices. Information is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.

188 Hillcrest Rd, New Holland, PA 17557 - Photo 1

Just Listed

$349,900

Open House

188 Hillcrest Rd New Holland, PA 17557

Single Family
Active
Updated 1 day ago

4
Beds
4
Total Baths
2,719
Sq. Ft.

Listed by Iron Valley Real Estate of Lancaster, Rachel Stoltzfus

118 E Broad St, New Holland, PA 17557 - Photo 1

Just Listed

$320,000

118 E Broad St New Holland, PA 17557

Single Family
Active
Updated 13 hours ago

3
Beds
3
Total Baths
1,452
Sq. Ft.

Listed by Kingsway Realty - Ephrata, Wendy L Stauffer

123 Center Ave, Terre Hill, PA 17581 - Photo 1

Just Listed

$425,000

Open House

123 Center Ave Terre Hill, PA 17581

Single Family
Active
Updated 2 days ago

3
Beds
3
Total Baths
1,525
Sq. Ft.

Listed by Horning Farm Agency Inc, Chelsea Kuska

4951 Horseshoe Pike, Honey Brook, PA 19344 - Photo 1

Just Listed

$325,000

Open House

4951 Horseshoe Pike Honey Brook, PA 19344

Single Family
Active
Updated 3 days ago

3
Beds
3
Total Baths
2,977
Sq. Ft.

Listed by EXP Realty, LLC, Matthew W Fetick

109 Azalea Cir, Honey Brook, PA 19344 - Photo 1

Price Reduced

-$1,000 (-1.25%)

$79,000

109 Azalea Cir Honey Brook, PA 19344

Mobile Home
Active
Updated 2 days ago

3
Beds
2
Total Baths

Listed by Springer Realty Group, Carol Jones

61 Violet Dr, Honey Brook, PA 19344 - Photo 1

61 Violet Dr Honey Brook, PA 19344

Mobile Home
Active
Updated 13 hours ago

3
Beds
2
Total Baths

Listed by Honest Real Estate, Kelsey Ryan and Honest Real Estate, jennifer beck

8 Cherokee Ln, Honey Brook, PA 19344 - Photo 1

Price Reduced

-$5,100 (-5.37%)

$89,900

8 Cherokee Ln Honey Brook, PA 19344

Mobile Home
Active
Updated 3 days ago

2
Beds
2
Total Baths
915
Sq. Ft.

Listed by LPT Realty, LLC, Gary A Mercer Sr. and LPT Realty, LLC, Nicole Courtney

20 Broad Ax Pass, Morgantown, PA 19543 - Photo 1

Price Reduced

-$12,900 (-2.69%)

$467,000

20 Broad Ax Pass Morgantown, PA 19543

Single Family
Active
Updated 1 day ago

3
Beds
2
Total Baths
1,772
Sq. Ft.

Listed by Main Street Real Estate Partners, Carl J Billera

1258 Main Street, East Earl, PA 17519 (MLS# PALA2079120) is a Single Family property that was sold at $419,000 on March 30, 2026. Want to learn more about 1258 Main Street? Do you have questions about finding other Single Family real estate for sale in East Earl? You can browse all East Earl real estate or contact a Coldwell Banker agent to request more information.

1258 Main St East Earl, PA 17519