Recently Viewed Properties
See This Home
Save This Listing
Close

View All Photos

$1,659,000 Just Listed

  • For Sale
  • Active
  • Single Family
  • 4 Beds
  • 3 Full Baths
  • 1 Partial Bath
  • 2,750 Sq. Ft.
  • Updated 3 days ago
See This Home
Save This Home
See This Home
Save This Home
An elegant and lovingly maintained antique colonial situated on 1.2 secluded acres near the Old Lyme Country Club. Recent updates include new landscaping front and back, new hardscaping around the pool deck, a new cedar roof, well tank, and a HVAC system including ductwork. The interior preserves the historic aspects of the home while graciously blending all the amenities of modern life. A formal living room and cozy library frame the front entryway, and lead to a large family room lined with walls of windows and French doors that bring in loads of natural light. Thoughtful classic architectural details throughout the home include wide-plank hardwood floors, custom built-in cabinetry, crown molding, and front and back stairwells. The cheery kitchen is placed conveniently off the dining area, again filled with more windows and French doors leading to the outside patio. With plenty of room for outdoor seating and dining, it is the perfect spot for entertaining friends and hosting family gatherings around the in-ground gunite pool and spa. A lush lawn beyond beckons for yard games and playing fetch with the dog. Upstairs are four distinctive bedrooms. The primary suite has an ensuite bathroom and walk-in closet. There is another bedroom with a second ensuite bath, and two more rooms that share a third bathroom.

Full Property Details for 25 Johnny Cake Hill Rd

General

  • Price: $1,659,000
  • Taxes: (July 2025-June 2026)
  • Status: Active
  • Type: Single Family
  • Source: SMARTMLS
  • MLS ID: 24201784
  • Updated: 9/3/2026
  • Added to Site: 3 day(s) ago

Interior

  • Number of Rooms: 8
  • Fireplace: Yes
  • Number of Fireplaces: 2
  • Appliances: Gas Cooktop, Microwave, Range Hood, Refrigerator, Dishwasher, Washer, Dryer

Rooms

Bathrooms

  • Total Bathrooms: 4
  • Full Bathrooms: 3
  • Half Bathrooms: 1

Bedrooms

  • Total Bedrooms: 4
  • Primary Suite: Wide Board Floor, 14.11 x 17.3, Upper
  • Bedroom 1: Bedroom - Wide Board Floor, 12.1 x 9.11, Upper
  • Bedroom 2: Bedroom - Wide Board Floor, 13.1 x 13.7, Upper
  • Bedroom 3: Bedroom - Wide Board Floor, 13.3 x 13.9, Upper

Other Rooms

  • Living Room: Living Room - Book Shelves, Built-Ins, Fireplace, Wide Board Floor, 23.9 x 20.1, Main
  • Kitchen: Kitchen - Breakfast Bar, Eating Space, 17.1 x 9.8, Main
  • Dining Room: Dining Room - Fireplace, French Doors, Wide Board Floor, 20.11 x 13.3, Main
  • Den: Den - Built-Ins, Wide Board Floor, 13.1 x 13.6, Main
  • Library: Library - Book Shelves, Built-Ins, Wide Board Floor, 14.7 x 13.6, Main

Additional Information

  • Pool: Yes
  • Pool Description: Gunite, In Ground Pool

Exterior

  • Exterior Features: Fruit Trees, Gutters, Garden Area, Lighting, French Doors, Patio
  • Color: Pink

Parking

  • Total Spaces: 5
  • Parking: Paved, Off Street Parking, Driveway

Location

  • County: New London
  • Neighborhood: Johnnycake Hill
  • Driving Directions: GPS friendly

School Information

  • Elementary School: Per Board of Ed
  • High School: Per Board of Ed

Community

  • Community Name: Johnnycake Hill

Heating & Cooling

  • Cooling Type: Central Air
  • Heating Type: Hot Air, Oil
  • Heating Fuel: Oil
  • Water Heater: Electric, 40 Gallon Tank

Utilities

  • Sewer: Septic
  • Water: Private Well

Structural Information

  • Architectural Style: Antique
  • Construction Status: No/Resale
  • Exterior Const.: Shingle
  • Basement Desc.: Full, Unfinished, Full With Hatchway
  • Roof: Wood Shingle
  • Attic: Yes
  • Square Feet: 2,750
  • Above Ground: 2,750 Sq. Ft.
  • Year Built: 1730

Lot Features

  • Lot Size (Acres): 1.2
  • Driveway/Sidewalk: Paved
  • Zoning: RU40
  • Lot Description: Lightly Wooded, Level Lot, Professionally Landscaped

Financial Considerations

  • Assessment Amount: $845,000
  • Tax Year: July 2025-June 2026

Disclosures and Reports

  • Property ID: 1552932

Listed by William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l, Susan Malan

Quickly Find Out More

* Indicates a required field

Yes, I would like more information. Please use and/or share my information with a Coldwell Banker ® affiliated agent to contact me about my real estate needs. By clicking Send Message, I request to be contacted by phone or text message and consent to being contacted by automated means. I understand that my consent to receive calls or texts is not a condition of purchasing any property, goods, or services. Alternatively, I understand that I can access real estate services by email or I can contact the agent myself.

If an Coldwell Banker affiliated agent is not available in the area where I need assistance, I agree to be contacted by a real estate agent affiliated with another brand owned or licensed by Anywhere Real Estate (BHGRE®, CENTURY 21®, Corcoran®, ERA®, or Sotheby’s International Realty®). I acknowledge that I have read and agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Notice.

We Value Your Privacy

Listing agent

— 25 Johnny Cake Hill Rd —

  • Susan Malan

    William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l

Agent Contact: (860) 767-5011 Office Contact: (860) 767-7488

Get Pre-Approved Today

Be ready to buy your new home!

with our affiliated lender
NMLS#: 1598647

Get Pre-Approved

Be ready to buy your new home!

with our affiliated lender
NMLS#: 1598647

Get Pre-Approved

Schools serving 25 Johnny Cake Hill Rd

School District:Regional School District 18
NameGradesDistance
Mile Creek School
205 Mile Creek Road, Old Lyme, CT 06371
K-52.2 mi
Lyme-Old Lyme Middle School
53 Lyme Street, Old Lyme, CT 06371
6-81.1 mi
Lyme-Old Lyme High School
69 Lyme Street, Old Lyme, CT 06371
9-121.2 mi
Disclaimer: School attendance boundaries provided by ATTOM Data Solutions and are for reference only. Contact the school directly to verify enrollment eligibility.

Price & Sales History for 25 Johnny Cake Hill Rd Get Price Alerts and Save Property

Date
Details
Price
Change
Source
9/03/2026
Listed
$1,659,000
58%
MLS
10/09/2025
Sold
$1,050,000
—
Public Record
Get Price Alerts and Save Property
Disclaimer: Historical sales information is derived from public records provided by the county offices. Information is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.

Tax History for 25 Johnny Cake Hill Rd

Year
Property Taxes
Change
Tax Assessment
Change
2025
$13,714
16%
$845,000
74%
2023
$11,822
4%
$484,500
—
2023
$11,386
—
$484,500
—
2022
$11,386
1%
$484,500
—
2021
$11,289
—
$484,500
—
2020
$11,240
-4%
$484,500
-7%
2019
$11,736
2%
$523,700
—
2018
$11,474
1%
$523,700
—
2017
$11,390
3%
$523,700
—
2016
$11,102
3%
$523,700
—
2015
$10,799
-3%
$523,700
-7%
2014
$11,110
2%
$565,100
—
2011
$10,906
—
$565,100
—
View All
Disclaimer: Historical tax information is derived from public records provided by the county offices. Information is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.

Estimate the Cost for 25 Johnny Cake Hill Rd

$
Down Payment
%
$
%

$
$

*These costs are estimates, and the interest rates assume exceptional credit standing.

Be ready to buy your new home!

with our affiliated lender
NMLS#: 1598647

Get Pre-Approved

Listed by William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l, Susan Malan

Similar Properties near 25 Johnny Cake Hill Rd

This is a carousel with tiles that activate property listing cards. Use the previous and next buttons to navigate.

138 N Cove Rd, Old Saybrook, CT 06475 - Photo 1 Just Listed
$1,599,000
Open House

138 N Cove Rd  Old Saybrook, CT 06475

  • Single Family
  • Active
  • Updated 2 days ago
  • 4
    Beds
  • 4
    Total Baths
  • 2,734
    Sq. Ft.
Listed by Marcello Delmonaco (203) 401-1931
81 Essex Rd, Old Saybrook, CT 06475 - Photo 1
$1,450,000

81 Essex Rd  Old Saybrook, CT 06475

  • Single Family
  • Active
  • 3
    Beds
  • 2
    Total Baths
  • 2,570
    Sq. Ft.
Listed by Serhant Connecticut, LLC
13 College St, Old Saybrook, CT 06475 - Photo 1
$1,590,000

13 College St  Old Saybrook, CT 06475

  • Single Family
  • Active
  • 4
    Beds
  • 3
    Total Baths
  • 2,070
    Sq. Ft.
Listed by William Raveis Real Estate
41 -1 Whippoorwill Rd, Old Lyme, CT 06371 - Photo 1
$1,899,999

41 -1 Whippoorwill Rd  Old Lyme, CT 06371

  • Single Family
  • Active
  • 4
    Beds
  • 4
    Total Baths
  • 3,345
    Sq. Ft.
Listed by William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l

Just Listed near 25 Johnny Cake Hill Rd

This is a carousel with tiles that activate property listing cards. Use the previous and next buttons to navigate.

138 N Cove Rd, Old Saybrook, CT 06475 - Photo 1 Just Listed
$1,599,000
Open House

138 N Cove Rd  Old Saybrook, CT 06475

  • Single Family
  • Active
  • Updated 2 days ago
  • 4
    Beds
  • 4
    Total Baths
  • 2,734
    Sq. Ft.
Listed by Marcello Delmonaco (203) 401-1931
25 Sheffield St, Old Saybrook, CT 06475 - Photo 1 Just Listed
$969,000

25 Sheffield St  #3  Old Saybrook, CT 06475

  • Townhouse
  • Active
  • Updated 4 days ago
  • 2
    Beds
  • 3
    Total Baths
  • 2,132
    Sq. Ft.
Listed by William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l
65 Research Pkwy, Old Saybrook, CT 06475 - Photo 1 Just Listed
$4,549

65 Research Pkwy  Old Saybrook, CT 06475

  • Commercial Lease
  • Active
Listed by Signature Properties of N.E.
108 Maple Ave, Old Saybrook, CT 06475 - Photo 1 Just Listed
$1,550,000

108 Maple Ave  Old Saybrook, CT 06475

  • Single Family
  • Active
  • Updated 4 days ago
  • 4
    Beds
  • 4
    Total Baths
  • 3,188
    Sq. Ft.
Listed by William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l

Price Reduced near 25 Johnny Cake Hill Rd

This is a carousel with tiles that activate property listing cards. Use the previous and next buttons to navigate.

104 Knollwood Dr, Old Saybrook, CT 06475 - Photo 1 Price Reduced
-$50,000 (-3.34%)
$1,445,000
Open House

104 Knollwood Dr  Old Saybrook, CT 06475

  • Single Family
  • Active
  • Updated 2 days ago
  • 3
    Beds
  • 2
    Total Baths
  • 1,809
    Sq. Ft.
Listed by The Walz Team at Coldwell Banker Realty (203) 619-4029
65 Knollwood Dr, Old Saybrook, CT 06475 - Photo 1 Price Reduced
-$50,000 (-4.78%)
$995,000

65 Knollwood Dr  Old Saybrook, CT 06475

  • Single Family
  • Active
  • Updated 5 days ago
  • 3
    Beds
  • 3
    Total Baths
  • 2,153
    Sq. Ft.
Listed by Martha Quaratella (860) 227-7611
24 W Shore Dr, Old Saybrook, CT 06475 - Photo 1 Price Reduced
-$20,000 (-1.61%)
$1,225,000

24 W Shore Dr  Old Saybrook, CT 06475

  • Single Family
  • Active
  • Updated 5 days ago
  • 3
    Beds
  • 1
    Total Bath
  • 884
    Sq. Ft.
Listed by William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l
17 College St, Old Saybrook, CT 06475 - Photo 1 Price Reduced
-$10,000 (-0.91%)
$1,089,000

17 College St  Old Saybrook, CT 06475

  • Single Family
  • Active
  • Updated 3 days ago
  • 3
    Beds
  • 3
    Total Baths
  • 1,960
    Sq. Ft.
Listed by Compass Connecticut, LLC

Recent Sales near 25 Johnny Cake Hill Rd

This is a carousel with tiles that activate property listing cards. Use the previous and next buttons to navigate.

8 Lieutenant River Ln, Old Lyme, CT 06371 - Photo 1 Sold
$1,500,000

8 Lieutenant River Ln  Old Lyme, CT 06371

  • Single Family
  • Closed
  • 3
    Beds
  • 3
    Total Baths
  • 2,215
    Sq. Ft.
Listed by William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l
Sold by William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l
1 & 3 Neck Rd, Old Lyme, CT 06371 - Photo 1 Sold
$1,725,000

1 & 3 Neck Rd  Old Lyme, CT 06371

  • Single Family
  • Closed
  • 4
    Beds
  • 4
    Total Baths
  • 6,742
    Sq. Ft.
Listed by William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l
Sold by Berkshire Hathaway NE Prop.
35 Sill Ln, Old Lyme, CT 06371 - Photo 1 Sold
$1,700,000

35 Sill Ln  Old Lyme, CT 06371

  • Single Family
  • Closed
  • Updated 5 days ago
  • 3
    Beds
  • 3
    Total Baths
  • 2,516
    Sq. Ft.
Listed by William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l
Sold by Nancy Mesham
70 -3 Sill Ln, Old Lyme, CT 06371 - Photo 1 Sold
$1,700,000

70 -3 Sill Ln  Old Lyme, CT 06371

  • Single Family
  • Closed
  • 4
    Beds
  • 5
    Total Baths
  • 5,160
    Sq. Ft.
Listed by Berkshire Hathaway NE Prop.
Sold by RE/MAX Alliance

25 Johnny Cake Hill Road, Old Lyme, CT 06371 (MLS# 24201784) is a Single Family property with 4 bedrooms, 3 full bathrooms and 1 partial bathroom. 25 Johnny Cake Hill Road is currently listed for $1,659,000 and was received on September 03, 2026. Want to learn more about 25 Johnny Cake Hill Road? Do you have questions about finding other Single Family real estate for sale in Old Lyme? You can browse all Old Lyme real estate or contact a Coldwell Banker agent to request more information.

Tour this property